Sisters’ Caribbean Cuisine

Reviews

• Crismeily A.

  star star star star star 15 July 2026

  Favorite Caribbean place in my hood. The jerk chicken and candied yams are to die for. The lemonade and sorrel mix, which I've never had together before, is my new favorite drink. I'm seriously there at least once a week for lunch. Great food. Great staff.

• Mickey C.

  star star star star star_border 10 July 2026

  Little cozy spot in Harlem.
  Food was yummy!
  
  I had the oxtail with rice and beans and added candied yam. Also had their homemade lemonade and coconut and pineapple cake.
  
  The oxtail was sweet and tender. I'd have it again.
  Coconut and pineapple cake was not overly sweet. It had (I think) a little bit of rum. I'm not a fan of rum but the rest of the cake was delicious!
  
  Friends had the curry chicken and rice. Another had the chicken roti with veggies. We all cleaned off our plates.
  
  They ran out of a few things, like the callalou, red velvet cake, and some other sides. I guess I'll have to come back to try again.
  
  Yes, they take cards.

• Tee M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 7 July 2026

  I came here with 5 friends last week.. the food tasted disgusting.. I'm not sure if the chef was having a bad day or something but the chicken was undercooked, oxtail had sugar and was over the top. Rice was dry...
  
  Listen .. I could've had a better time at Popeyes.. save your money and do not bother coming here.. the food was terrible
  
  Even the yams!! How do you mess up yams??
  
  But yeah don't waste your time here.

• Cynthia A.

  star star star star star_border 25 June 2026

  We stopped by here after Curlfest because we refused to spend money on food trucks at the park for fear of long lines and small portions.
  
  Sister's was not too far from the shuttle stop drop off for curl fest so it was very convenient to get to. Before I start off my review I'd like to if this was any other kind of restaurant it would have been a 3 start review BUT you know how the say if the Caribbean women taking your order at the counter is rude than it's going to be a great meal, well that's what this place was like. No one was flat out rude to us but the customer service was not great.
  
  The place is small so when we walked in every seat was filled ( more people from curlfest!). No one acknowledged my parties presence until I finally had to go up to a waitress and ask about a potential wait time ( they didn't have one ) We were so hungry we decide to just wait it out because it seems a party would leave in about 10 minutes.
  
  Once we sat down the tables were not wiped down, only the plates and cups were taken away. We heard the oxtails were really good so a couple of people in my party were going to order that, I wanted jerk chicken. THEY RAN OUT OF OXTAILS to the disappointment of my party.  We all ordered jerk chicken meals ( it was really spicy for anyone that doesn't like heat )
  
  All in all , I'm not sure if the volume of people coming in took them off guard. But the customer service/ experience was not great but the food is 5 stars. I'm willing to make the trip from NJ to Harlem just to experience the oxtails on a less busy day. I'll keep y'all updated.

• Brandon D.

  star star star star star 24 June 2026

  Amazing! Found this true gem, and am looking forward to the next time I return. The interior here is super cozy and warm. Makes me feel like I stepped into Grandmaw's house. The menu is pretty extensive, with a wide variety of dishes to peak your interest. I went with the Roti, which was absolutely phenomenal. If you like spicy curries, this one was on par with some of the best I've had! Others with me got the browned chicken, which also had stellar reviews. The portion of food you get here for the price is absolutely a steal!
  Come here, enjoy the open air vibes and get ready to leave FULL.